Couldn’t help but post about this. A few days ago the Guardian had an article about two Dunkin Donuts in Buffalo NY which are using facial recognition software to analyze their clientele and serve contextual advertising to them based on their demographic appeal, and possible current or past purchases.
The article mentions Minority Report and it is the first thing I thought of. Does this look familiar to anyone?
I don’t think I’m the only one who considers this creepy. I’ve always had an interest in economics, and as my career has progressed I have found it interesting to see marketing’s role in an economic system. In a perfect market, all information is distributed freely and instantaneously. This allows customers to know exactly what kind of service, options, pricing, products, etc are available and how they match with their own personal values. When product A reaches a point where it will deliver more utils (an economic term for units of satisfaction) than product B the consumer will purchase product A.
I believe marketing’s function, to a degree, is to spread the message about your company’s product or service and how it fits into the marketplace. Maybe its the lowest cost option, highest quality, longest lasting, lowest maintenance, best tasting, healthiest, etc. This arms the consumer with the information and validation they need to move forward with a purchasing decision.
There are a number of widgets and programs available that help accomplish this now (some we’ve even built.) They range from the Southwest Ding to a standard threshold buying profile on any MLS program. This allows me, or you, to set our buying thresholds - I’m interested in buying product A or a reasonable alternative, for X dollars. And when a product or service that matches that threshold is available, it lets you know, and you can move forward buying it if you like. To me, that is helpful. It saves me time, and helps ensure I am getting a deal I am interested in.
My concern with the contextual system put in place at these Dunkin Donuts is that they will simply make guesses based on your demographic profile. Sure some taste will overlap among people, but for the most part this feels like an invasion of my privacy which doesn’t benefit me. The cost of my privacy is X dollars to the advertiser interested in reaching MALE DEMOGRAPHIC 25-45.
I don’t mind being marketed to, but if you want me to be responsive and embrace your company and product, them market to me on my terms, not yours. Am I alone here?


